Updated Nov 20, 2026· 9 min read

Key takeaways

  • Compare five earplugs for sleeping, from soft foam and moldable silicone putty to low-profile reusable plugs, with noise ratings, fit notes and care tips.

A quiet bedroom is the foundation of a calm night, and earplugs are the simplest way to build one when the world outside will not cooperate. A snoring partner, traffic at dawn, or a neighbor’s late television can all keep you awake, and a well-chosen plug turns that noise down far enough for sleep to arrive. The five plugs below cover the three main designs: soft disposable foam, moldable silicone putty, and low-profile reusable silicone.

They differ in the ways that matter at bedtime. Foam plugs expand inside the ear canal and carry the highest published noise ratings, putty plugs mold to the shape of any ear and sit flush against the head, and reusable plugs offer a custom fit with replaceable tips and a lower profile for side sleepers. Each pick lists its published noise rating, material, pack size, and fit notes.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Quick answer

For most sleepers, the Mack’s Ultra Soft Foam Earplugs are the strongest all-round pick, with a published Noise Reduction Rating of 33 decibels in a 50-pair jar. Choose the Mack’s Dreamgirl if your ear canals run small, the Mack’s Pillow Soft putty if foam feels too deep, the Loop Quiet 2 for a reusable low-profile fit, and the Alpine SleepDeep for a shaped reusable plug built for side sleepers.

1. Mack’s Ultra Soft Foam Earplugs, 50 Pair

Mack's Ultra Soft Foam Earplugs, 50 Pair

Mack's Ultra Soft Foam Earplugs, 50 Pair

Check price on Amazon

The Ultra Soft is the flagship foam plug in the Mack’s line, and it leads this roundup on its published numbers. The maker publishes a Noise Reduction Rating of 33 decibels, the highest rating it lists for any of its plugs, and the foam is a low-pressure, slow-release polyurethane that compresses easily and expands gently to fill the canal. That combination suits light sleepers in noisy flats and shift workers sleeping through daytime traffic.

The jar holds 50 pairs, which makes it the practical choice for nightly use without rationing. The plugs are beige, tapered, and made in the United States, and the safety-sealed jar has a flip-open top that keeps the remaining pairs clean on a nightstand. Foam plugs are disposable, so each pair stays fresh for a few nights before it gets replaced. This is the budget pick for anyone who wants the strongest published rating in the simplest form.

Specs

  • Noise Reduction Rating: 33 dB, per the listing
  • Material: Comfy Cush low-pressure slow-release polyurethane foam
  • Pack: 50 pairs in a safety-sealed jar with a flip-open top
  • Model: 9250
  • Made in: United States
  • Jar size: about 4.25 x 2.52 x 2.52 inches, per a retailer listing of the same model

2. Mack’s Dreamgirl Soft Foam Earplugs, 50 Pair, Pink

Mack's Dreamgirl Soft Foam Earplugs, 50 Pair, Pink

Mack's Dreamgirl Soft Foam Earplugs, 50 Pair, Pink

Check price on Amazon

The Dreamgirl solves a narrow but common problem: standard foam plugs that feel too large. Mack’s designed this plug about a fifth smaller than its standard foam, with a hollow, flared, contoured body that the maker says maximizes comfort during sleep, especially for people with small or sensitive ear canals. If a full-size foam plug has ever pressed or ached by morning, this is the plug to try next.

The listing title gives a Noise Reduction Rating of 30 decibels and a Single Number Rating of 33 decibels, so the smaller size gives up little on paper. The foam matches the standard line, and the pink color makes the pair easy to spot on a nightstand. Fifty pairs come in the pack, so it works as a nightly staple just like the Ultra Soft. This is the budget to mid-range pick for small ears and side sleepers who want foam without the bulk.

Specs

  • Noise Reduction Rating: 30 dB, per the listing title
  • Single Number Rating: 33 dB, per the listing title
  • Material: low-pressure tapered polyurethane foam
  • Fit: smaller contoured plug with a hollow, flared body for small or sensitive ear canals
  • Pack: 50 pairs, pink
  • Made in: United States

3. Mack’s Pillow Soft Silicone Earplugs, 12 Pair

Mack's Pillow Soft Silicone Earplugs, 12 Pair

Mack's Pillow Soft Silicone Earplugs, 12 Pair

Check price on Amazon

The Pillow Soft is a different idea altogether: a moldable silicone putty that you press over the ear opening instead of rolling and inserting into the canal. Because the putty molds to the unique contours of any ear, it seals without depth, which suits sleepers who dislike the feeling of foam expanding inside the ear. The maker has sold this design since 1962, and it is also waterproof, so the same plug works for swimming and bathing.

The listing publishes a Noise Reduction Rating of 22 decibels, lower than the foam picks here, and a European Single Number Rating of 30 decibels. That gap is normal for putty plugs, which seal at the surface rather than deep in the canal, and the comfort trade is often worth it for sensitive ears. Twelve pairs come in the pack, and the silicone is non-toxic, BPA-free, and made in the United States. This is the mid-range pick for anyone who finds foam plugs uncomfortable or who wants one plug for sleep and water.

Specs

  • Noise Reduction Rating: 22 dB, per the listing
  • Single Number Rating: 30 dB, per the maker
  • Material: moldable silicone putty, non-toxic and BPA-free
  • Fit: molds to the contours of any ear; sits at the ear opening rather than deep in the canal
  • Pack: 12 pairs
  • Made in: United States
  • Also: waterproof, for swimming and bathing

4. Loop Quiet 2 Ear Plugs, Black

Loop Quiet 2 Ear Plugs, Black

Loop Quiet 2 Ear Plugs, Black

Check price on Amazon

The Loop Quiet 2 is the reusable pick for sleepers who want a plug they can wash and wear night after night. It is made from flexible silicone with a low-profile loop shape that sits almost flush against the ear, so it presses far less into a pillow than a foam plug does. Eight ear tips in four sizes, from extra small to large, come in the box, so finding a seal that holds through the night is easier.

The maker publishes a Single Number Rating of 24 decibels, a gentler figure than the foam picks, and that is by design: the Quiet 2 muffles snoring, traffic, and household noise without sealing the world out completely, so an alarm or a child calling still comes through. The model number is en-qt-blk-03, and the listing first appeared in June 2024 as the successor to the original Loop Quiet. This is the mid-range to premium pick for side sleepers and for anyone who prefers one reusable pair over a jar of disposables.

Specs

  • Single Number Rating: 24 dB, per the maker
  • Material: flexible silicone, reusable
  • Fit: low-profile loop shape; 8 ear tips in XS, S, M, and L
  • Model: en-qt-blk-03
  • Date first available: June 6, 2024
  • Use: sleep, focus, travel, and noise sensitivity

5. Alpine SleepDeep Multisize Earplugs, 2-Pair

Alpine SleepDeep Multisize Earplugs, 2-Pair, S + M/L

Alpine SleepDeep Multisize Earplugs, 2-Pair, S + M/L

Check price on Amazon

The Alpine SleepDeep is built for side sleepers from the ground up. Its 3D oval shape follows the shape of the ear canal rather than forcing a round plug into it, and a noise-reducing gel inside the AlpineThermoShape material softens the plug further as it warms to body temperature. The result sits low in the ear and stays comfortable when your head turns into the pillow.

The maker publishes a Noise Reduction Rating of 27 decibels, and each pair is reusable up to one hundred times with proper care, which makes the two-pair multisize pack a long-lasting choice. The pack includes one pair in size S and one pair in size M/L, so you can try both and keep the one that seals best. This is the premium pick for side sleepers who want a shaped, reusable plug with a stronger rating than the Loop.

Specs

  • Noise Reduction Rating: 27 dB, per the maker
  • Material: AlpineThermoShape with noise-reducing gel
  • Shape: 3D oval, designed for side sleepers
  • Pack: 2 pairs, reusable, in sizes S and M/L
  • Reusability: up to 100 times with proper care
  • Use: sleeping and concentration

How to choose

Begin with fit, because the plug that seals best is the plug that works best. Foam plugs need a correct roll, insert, and hold while they expand, and a plug that is too large will ache by morning. If standard foam has ever felt too big, try the smaller Dreamgirl before giving up on foam. If foam of any size feels too deep, switch to putty, which seals at the surface, or to a reusable plug with multiple tip sizes.

Next, compare the published ratings with care. Foam plugs publish a Noise Reduction Rating, while reusable plugs often publish a Single Number Rating, and the two scales are not directly comparable. Within one scale, a higher number means more attenuation in laboratory conditions, but a comfortable seal matters more than a few decibels on paper. Then decide between disposable and reusable: a jar of foam is the simplest nightly routine, while a reusable pair needs washing but lasts far longer.

Finally, think about how you sleep. Side sleepers should favor low-profile designs like the Loop Quiet 2 or the Alpine SleepDeep, which sit flush and press less into the pillow. Back sleepers can use any design comfortably. If you need to hear an alarm, lean toward the gentler reusable plugs rather than the highest-rated foam.

Who should skip

Skip foam plugs entirely if you have sensitive ear canals that ache from any inserted plug, since even soft foam expands inside the canal; putty or a shallow reusable tip is the kinder route. Skip the Pillow Soft putty if you need the strongest published rating, since its 22 decibel figure sits well below the foam picks here. Skip the Loop Quiet 2 if you need maximum blocking for a very loud environment, since its 24 decibel figure is designed to muffle rather than seal out sound.

Also skip reusable plugs if you will not wash them regularly, since a plug worn nightly collects earwax and needs cleaning to stay hygienic. And note the Pillow Soft listing caution: do not use putty plugs for more than five consecutive days, to prevent earwax buildup or ear canal irritation. If you sleep with plugs every night, rotate between foam and putty, or take a night off each week.

FAQ

Are foam earplugs safe to wear all night?

Yes, for most people, soft foam plugs designed for sleep are made to be worn through the night. Roll each plug, insert it gently, and hold it while the foam expands. Replace disposable pairs after a few nights, and stop using any plug that causes pain or itching.

Do earplugs block an alarm clock?

They reduce sound rather than removing it completely, so a loud alarm or a phone alarm set to vibrate on the nightstand usually still wakes most sleepers. Reusable plugs with lower published ratings, like the Loop Quiet 2, let more sound through than high-rated foam, which is the safer choice if you worry about sleeping through an alarm.

How do you clean reusable earplugs?

Wash silicone plugs with mild soap and warm water, rinse well, and let them dry fully before storing them in their case. Replace the ear tips when they lose their shape or no longer seal well. Keep disposable foam plugs dry and replace them after a few nights of use.

Which earplugs are best for side sleepers?

Low-profile plugs suit side sleepers best, because they sit flush against the ear and press less into the pillow. The Alpine SleepDeep is shaped for side sleeping, the Loop Quiet 2 has a flat loop design, and the smaller Dreamgirl foam plug is the best disposable option for side sleepers with small ears.

Final verdict

For a main bedroom, buy the Mack’s Ultra Soft Foam Earplugs: the published 33 decibel rating and the 50-pair jar cover nightly use with the least fuss. Choose the Dreamgirl if your ear canals run small, the Pillow Soft putty if foam feels too deep, the Loop Quiet 2 for a washable low-profile pair, and the Alpine SleepDeep for a shaped reusable plug built for side sleepers. Any of the five will make a noisy bedroom feel calmer within one night.

A
admin
We compare specs, materials and verified owner reviews before a product earns a spot. Rankings are never paid.
Affiliate disclosure. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices accurate as of the date shown.
Best Earplugs for Sleeping: 5 Picks for Quieter…Check price on Amazon